I’ve been running Windows Vista for a few months now but this notion just hit me today. If you’ve been running XP and plan to upgrade to Vista, expect to feel about the same as you did when you upgraded to Windows 98 from 95. There’s a bit more polish (if you’re running Aero), some of the included apps have been updated a bit, and it generally feels like a newer environment. It’s like coming home and finding someone painted your house and cleaned your carpets, but it’s still in the same neighborhood and your neighbor still wears a Speedo while mowing the lawn. But it’s not a huge update by any means. It doesn’t feel any faster than XP. Until you turn off UAC, it’s A LOT more annoying with all the pop up boxes asking your permission to do routine tasks. It’s probably what a lot of people are going to believe XP should have been in the first place.
Microsoft will focus on telling us how all the “plumbing” has been updated. It’s like the car salesman who describes all the engine enhancements to the car you’re driving that hasn’t change much a year or two later. Microsoft is in a tough situation. People who know how to keep their computers safe and spyware/adware free probably won’t notice much difference if they upgrade. With each Window iteration we’re told the new version is more secure, faster and has more features. That may have been the case going from Windows 3.1 to Windows 95 and from Windows 98/ME to XP. But Vista doesn’t feel worth the $150-$200 upgrade hit if you’re not having problems with XP. Maybe the people who will benefit the most are the clueless computer users who’s machines are infested with spyware. Having UAC turned on by default might protect those users from themselves. Only time will tell.
Microsoft has distilled the main features (and supposedly the main reasons you’d want to upgrade) down to this simple list on the Vista website.
User Experience – Marginally better than XP. I’ve noticed that working with photos is a bit easier in Vista. If you put a pretty skin XP, does that make for a better user experience? Maybe so, according to MS.
Security – Seems strange to me that we are expected to pony up more money to make our OS more secure. Shouldn’t it have been secure in the first place? And if it’s so secure, why do I need Windows Live OneCare ? Maybe it is more secure but it’s a lot more naggy. I’m certain power users will just disable UAC making it less secure.
Search & Organization – I haven’t *felt* anymore organized using Vista. Thankfully, search has been simplified and you’re not greeted by an obnoxious dog the first time you launch search.
Internet Explorer 7 – You don’t need Vista to run this. You can download it for free on XP. Or you can run the much better Firefox.
Sidebar & Gadgets – You can run Desktop Sidebar on XP which has many more available gadgets and takes up far less memory. Sidebar in Vista is nice looking though.
Performance – You’ll read about Superfetch and Readyboost. How about just making the OS faster from the ground up without requiring additional hardware?
Windows Backup – This is by far the strongest reason to upgrade to Vista. I used to take images of my machine using Acronis, but with Vista’s built in imaging/backup that’s a thing of the past. I’ve used this feature to roll back to a previous version and it worked very well. For me, this is the one killer feature of Vista.
Networking – Sounds like a feature aimed at MIS departments which is fine but networking in XP wasn’t that difficult to begin with, was it?
Windows Sideshow – Allows laptop makers to include a secondary screen, say on the front cover where you can view information without booting up the laptop. This seems like a feature Scoble would suggest for his beloved Tablet.
Speech Recognition – Probably a nice feature for a small group of people. Not a big deal for the rest of us who don’t want to look like dorks talking to our computers.
Help & Feedback – Huh? All I’ve noticed is that whenever an application hangs, Vista tries to call the mothership and report the problem. This helps me how?
Windows Update – Haven’t we had this for a few years now? What has been improved? After installing RC2, I ran Windows Update and it found an updated driver for my chipset. I installed it and it hosed the machine. On the bright side, I was able to test the backup and restore features!
I will be running Windows Vista on all my computers going forward. Maybe my expectations were out of whack. Maybe XP was a better OS than many of us give it credit for. Whatever the reasons, I’m resigned to the fact that the days of the exciting upgrade experience I had going from 3.1 to 95 are over. Windows has improved to the point where it would take a lot more than some cosmetic updates and a few improved applications to make me excited about an OS.
Update: A coworker showed me something pretty cool in Vista today. If you go to Search off the start menu and search for say, ‘device’, you can launch Device Driver or nearly any other area of Vista that would normally take several clicks.